On the Value of So-Called “Alkalising” Diets

“Alkalising” diets are gaining popularity, and while the diet itself may be good and healthy, the thinking behind it is anything but. It is based on a complete misunderstanding of human anatomy and body chemistry. Let me explain.

Acid-alkaline chemistry is crucial in physiology, both at the cell level and the level of the complete body. There are two reasons for this: Many of the major chemical components of the body can themselves act as acids and/or alkalines. This means that proteins contain both acidic and alkaline groups and their functions are highly dependent on pH. Virtually every important metabolic process involves the uptake or release of hydrogen ions, so that being alive tends to change the surrounding pH – usually reducing it – and this will sooner or later kill the body in the absence of buffering agents.

Respiration, which is the most important physiological activity of a cell, is an acid-producing process. Carbohydrates are broken down into carbon dioxides and thus into carbonic acid, H2CO3.

The weak organic acids in the foods are in part in the form of sodium or potassium salts. So, when the body balances its pH level, some of the carbon dioxide (CO2) produced by metabolizing these food acids, it converts the acids into bicarbonate (M+ HCO3-). Do I need to tell you whether bicarbonate is acid or alkaline?

The acid-alkaline balance of the body is regulated by two general mechanisms, selective excretion of acids or alkalines and by the buffering action of weak acid-alkaline systems in body fluids. Over a 24h period, an adult human will eliminate carbonic acid which breaks down into carbon dioxide, which exits from the lungs. Kidneys also excrete lesser amounts of acid.

The major buffering system of the body is the carbonate system, and it exists mainly in the form of HCO3- at the normal physiological pH. Secondary buffering action is done by phosphate, proteins and other weak organic acids and hemoglobin in the blood cells.

No foods can change the pH of your body. Your stomach is so acidic – it evolved to be that way – that no food can change its acidity. All food that leaves your stomach is adicic. After leaving your stomach food enters your intestines, where pancreatic secretions neutralise the stomach acids. So it does not matter what you eat, the food in your stomach is acidic and the food in your intestines is alkaline. I know that “alkalising” cancer quacks claim that cancer cells cannot live in an alkaline environment, and that actually is true. What they leave out is that neither can any other cell of your body. So were you actually able to “alkalise” your body, you’d be very dead.

It’s actually a very good thing that you cannot “alkalise” your blood more than temporarily, as deviations from the normal blood pH of 7.4 by more than about 0.1 either way can be very serious. Some people who peddle “alkalising” claim that range of “healthy body pH is 6.0-7.5.” The term for anyone with a blood pH of 6.0 or lower is ‘dead’. Anyone with a blood pH of 7.0 is in deep trouble, and very close to death.

The easiest way of actually “alkalising” your blood is by hyperventilating. Give it a go, till your lips tingle and hands cramp – and then tell me how great you felt. If you still want to “alkalise” your blood, you can advance to depressurisation and dehydration. Be warned, though, alkalosis is a pretty painful way to die.

What you really can “alkalise” is your urine, and all “alkalising” woo peddlers capitalise on this fact. They huckster urine tests to determine whether your body is too “acidic” and then sell you books or products that won’t actually do anything at all about your body pH, only about your urine pH. There just is no evidence whatsoever that intentionally alkalising your urine prevents or treats disease.

This is why following an “alkalising” diet or buying “alkalising” supplements to cure or prevent cancer is a complete waste of time and money.

About these ads

9 responses to “On the Value of So-Called “Alkalising” Diets

  1. One of the claims of “live blood” quacks is that they can diagnose blood pH microscopically and then prescribe diets to correct this. Which amazingly almost always turn out to be alkalising diets, through one of those coincidences like chirporactors always finding subluxations and Slippery Stand Burzynski always finding that antineoplastons are just the treatment for your cancer.

    • Since Robert O. Young is a main proponent of these alkalising diets AND the creator of the “live blood” analysis, it’s quite clear why alkalising diets are recommended by them. He also claimed to cure cancer with such diets, and Kim Tinkham followed the protocol, all the way to her death from cancer.

      • Indeed. I wonder if all “live blood” quacks have been trained by Young? I guess not, but with absolutely no certification or training requirements it’s impossible to say. I’ve been looking at one, Errol Denton, a thoroughly unpleasant man whose claims to medical expertise are somewhat undermined by his idea that the common cold is caused by the bacteria in your gut and can thus be cured by colon cleansing. How do people get away with publishing such complete twaddle and yet still maintain a healthy pool of victims?

        • That I don’t know, but I can find out, probably. It’ll take a bit of googling. Yes, I’m familiar with Errol and his blog – last I heard it was defunct again – and his complete lack of medical knowledge. If it ever returns, I just might lift some real howlers from it. I don’t know how he manages to dupe so many people, but I suspect his victims have very little knowledge about diseases and what causes them.

          • In passing, I am not a little involved in the fact that Errol’s blog was nuked multiple times. His response was to make a complaint to the police of racial harassment. Pure Ali G: It’s because I’s a quack, isn’t it?

  2. So were you actually able to “alkalise” your body, you’d be very dead.

    Very true, and is that like the Best Line Ever, or what!! :)

  3. Pingback: Weekend Reading « Science-Based Pharmacy

  4. PammyWhammy

    There is still value in the alkalising diet in treating interstitial cystitis

    • Yes, because it is a bladder condition. As the alkaline diet – as I mentioned – can only lower the acidity of the urine, it will help with this condition, and possibly other bladder diseases.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s